How to Break in a Baseball Glove

New baseball gloves often come stiff and need to be broken in before they’re ready for game play. To get your glove field-ready, here’s a guide on the best practices, things to avoid, and professional tips.

Traditional Methods

The classic approach to breaking in a new glove involves simply playing catch. By spending multiple hours over several days or weeks practicing with your glove, you’ll naturally break it in. This method, though time-consuming, effectively molds the glove to your hand and improves its performance. The more you use it, the quicker it will break in.

Using a Mallet

Another technique involves using a glove mallet. This tool helps soften and shape the glove’s palm and pocket. Gently pound the glove’s palm and pocket area with the mallet, focusing on the pocket. This helps the glove form to the shape of the ball and your hand more quickly.

Using Glove Oils and Conditioners

• Conditioners: Apply a small amount of conditioner, usually in paste form, in a similar manner. Conditioners evaporate more quickly than oils but still help keep the leather supple and prevent it from becoming hard or brittle. Because they may need to be reapplied more frequently, conditioners can help maintain the glove’s flexibility without adding extra weight. We recommend using conditioner in the palm only.

Things to Avoid

• Excessive Heat: Avoid using direct heat sources like hairdryers, microwaves, ovens or steamers as they can damage the leather.
• Too Much Oil/Conditioner: Over-applying oil or conditioner can weigh down the glove or cause the leather to become overly soft, heavy and lose its shape.

By combining these methods—playing catch regularly, using a mallet to shape the palm, and applying appropriate leather care products—you’ll break in your glove effectively and ensure it’s game-ready.